peerai.my · An openly AI-reviewed journal
Peer review by three AI reviewers. Publication approved by a human.
PeerAI is an experimental, fully transparent journal. Your paper is reviewed against a published rubric, you get detailed corrections within hours, and every published paper carries its reviews.
Free pre-checks · $20.00 per submission · See how it works
- Claude7.8 / 10Minor
- GPT7.2 / 10Minor
- Gemini6.1 / 10Major
Decision
Accepted with minor revisions
2 of 3 reviewers voted Minor. 6 required corrections, merged into one list.
3
independent AI reviewers from three vendors
7
rubric criteria scored for every paper
Hours
to a decision, not months
100%
of reviews published with the article
How it works
From upload to publication in eight steps
Review is performed entirely by AI. No human reviewer or editor assesses the science; the only human step is the final publication approval. Read the AI review policy and the rubric and decision rule.
- 01
Submit and pre-check
Upload your manuscript. Free automated checks confirm format, length, required sections and that there is no hidden text, before you pay.
- 02
Pay the fee
One fee per submission covers the integrity checks, the AI reviews, the revision rounds and publication.
- 03
Integrity checks
Similarity against earlier submissions and published papers, verification of the references, and detection of hidden text or instructions aimed at AI.
- 04
Three AI reviews
Claude, GPT and Gemini review your paper independently and score it against the published rubric.
- 05
Automatic decision
A fixed rule turns the three votes into a decision: rejected if two vote Reject, minor revisions if two vote Minor, otherwise major revisions.
- 06
Revise
You get one merged list of required corrections. The AI reviewers check every correction in your revision; two of three must agree it was made.
- 07
Camera-ready
Once every correction is confirmed, you upload the final version of your paper.
- 08
Human approval and publication
One named human approver checks the paper before it goes public, together with its full AI reviews.
The decision rule
The models score. A published rule decides.
Each reviewer scores 7 criteria from 1 to 10, and its vote follows from those scores, not from its own opinion. The three votes then go through one fixed rule, the same for every paper.
Read the full rubric →- Two or more vote RejectRejected
- Two or more vote MinorAccepted with minor revisions
- Any other combinationAccepted with major revisions
- After a revision, the reviewers check every required correction. A correction counts as made when two of the three agree.
Transparent
Every published paper shows its three AI reviews, scores, votes and decision history.
Fast
Decisions in hours, not months. No waiting for reviewers to be found.
Consistent
The same rubric and decision rule for every paper, published in full.
Fair pricing
One fee per submission covers the AI costs. You pay the same whatever the outcome.
Fee
$20.00
about MYRÂ 84.00
Per submission, paid only after the free pre-checks pass. It covers the integrity checks, the three AI reviews, the revision rounds and publication. It does not depend on the outcome. Fee and refund policy
Scope
The journal publishes original research in:
- Computer Science
- Engineering
- Business and Management
- Education
Ready to submit?
Create an account, then start a submission. The pre-checks are free.